The Veterans Millennium Health Care and Benefits Act (Millennium Act) authorizes the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to cover emergency care for conditions not related to veterans' service-connected disabilities when veterans who have no other health plan coverage receive care at non-VA providers. However, GAO identified a number of instances where VA staff who processed claims did not comply with applicable requirements of the Millennium Act, its implementing regulations, or VA policies when they denied the claims. Specifically, at the four VA facilities included in this review, GAO found 66 instances of noncompliance among the 128 denied claims reviewed, which led some claims to be inappropriately denied. VA facilities subsequently reconsidered and paid 25 of these claims. GAO also found that VA facilities may not be notifying veterans as required that their Millennium Act claims have been denied. Eighty-three claims out of 128 that GAO reviewed lacked documentation that the veteran was notified of the denial or of his or her appeal rights. These findings suggest that veterans whose claims have been inappropriately denied may have been held financially liable for emergency care that VA should have covered, and they may not be aware of their rights to appeal these denials.
GAO also found that, as a result of weaknesses in VA's oversight of Millennium Act claims, VA facilities are at risk for inappropriately denying such claims. For example, agency oversight activities do not focus on compliance with all applicable requirements but rather on the timeliness of claims processing. In addition, VA has limited assurance that deficiencies relating to Millennium Act claims processing identified during reviews are corrected because it only conducts limited follow-up with VA facilities. Moreover, VA does not collect adequate data for monitoring the appropriateness of Millennium Act claim denials. This lack of data hinders VA's ability to track patterns as to why Millennium Act claims are denied and identify areas where communications with veterans and non-VA providers about Millennium Act emergency care benefits could be improved.
VA has used various methods to educate veterans about their Millennium Act eligibility; however, VA officials, non-VA providers, and representatives of veterans service organizations told GAO that veterans still lack knowledge about their eligibility. For example, VA officials reported that because some veterans were uninformed about their eligibility, these veterans may have delayed or avoided seeking treatment at local non-VA providers, choosing instead to go to a less accessible VA facility. Because VA does not require facilities to conduct evaluations of veterans' understanding of Millennium Act eligibility, it lacks information needed to address potential gaps in veterans' knowledge about these benefits. Also, the non-VA providers GAO interviewed cited communication challenges with VA regarding Millennium Act claims, such as not having a specific point of contact at VA for directing specific questions and raising concerns, and a lack of VA responsiveness when issues are raised. Despite VA's efforts to improve communications with non-VA providers after a 2011 customer service survey revealed significant issues, these challenges persisted at the facilities GAO visited.
VA spent an estimated $418 million on Millennium Act emergency care claims in fiscal year 2012 and projects spending will increase to $580 million by fiscal year 2015. GAO was asked to review VA's administration of the emergency care benefit under the act. This report examines the extent to which (1) selected VA facilities complied with applicable requirements, in particular when denying claims; (2) VA's oversight activities ensure that Millennium Act claims are not inappropriately denied; and (3) veterans understand the Act's emergency care benefit and how VA communicates with non-VA providers about Millennium Act claims.
To do this work, GAO reviewed 4 VA facilities out of 142 based on variations in Millennium Act spending levels and geographic location. GAO also reviewed VA documents—including 128 denied Millennium Act claims from these four facilities—and interviewed officials from VA, non-VA providers, and veterans service organizations. These results cannot be generalized across VA but provide insights.